内容正文:
Never Defeated
Exploring Character and Spirit in The Old Man and the Sea
The Old Man and the Sea / Ernest Hemingway
Day 1:
Nothing.
Day 20:
Nothing.
Day 40:
Nothing.
Day 84: Still nothing.
Imagine:
You are a fisherman.
For 84 days
you catch nothing.
People laugh at you.
Will you go to the sea tomorrow?
But one old man did.
His name is Santiago.
From the novel The Old Man and the Sea
Big Question
Is Santiago winning or losing?
Today we will read the story to find the answer.
Read quickly and answer:
Fast Reading
1 What is Santiago doing?
2 What difficulty does he face?
Understanding the Situation
Santiago is:
fighting a huge fish
extremely tired
almost out of strength
Mission
Find evidence from the text.
What kind of man is Santiago?
Group Task
Group 1
Find evidence of physical struggle
Group 2
Find evidence of mental struggle
Group 3
Find evidence of respect for the fish
Group 1 Physical
Examples:
• He felt faint.
• His hands were mushy.
• He could hardly see.
Question:
What does this show?
Conclusion 1
Santiago is
strong and determined
Group 2 Mental
Examples:
• “Clear up, head.”
• “I will try it again.”
Question:What does this show?
Conclusion 1
Santiago is persistent
He never gives up.
Group 3 Respect
Examples:
Question:Why does he respect the fish?
• “You have a right.”
• “Never have I seen a greater or more noble thing than you.”
Conclusion 1
Santiago is
noble and respectful
Character Summary
determined
brave
persistent
noble
Santiago is
Conflict analysis
Man vs Nature
What is Santiago fighting against?
the sea
the fish
himself
The greatest battle is often against ourselves.
Why does Santiago respect the fish?
Think and discuss
A true hero respects his opponent.
Life connection
What about us?
Have you ever tried
very hard
but still failed?
What helped you
continue?
Is Santiago winning or losing?
Think again.
Physically
he may lose.
Spiritually
he wins.
As long as a person keeps fighting,
he is never defeated.
“A man can be destroyed
but not defeated.”
Santiago may lose the fish. But he never loses his courage. And maybe in life, what matters most
is not whether we win, but whether we keep fighting.
$