内容正文:
Unit 4 Stage and Screen
Good Book, Bad Movie?
Objectives
To obtain factual information on “Good book, bad movie? ”
To analyze how the author develops his ideas.
To express opinions towards “Good book, bad movie? ”
To talk about reasons why movie adaptations are less satisfying than the original books.
2
Pre-reading
《骆驼祥子》
《京华烟云》
《伊利亚特》
《夏洛克·福尔摩斯》
《了不起的盖茨比》
《红楼梦》
Have you ever read any of these books?
What are they about?
3
Good Book, Bad Movie?
adaptations (movies based on books)
Have you ever seen the movies or TV plays based on the books above?
Pre-reading
Good Book, Bad Movie?
Pre-reading
A. Exposition 说明文
B. Argumentation 议论文
C. Narration 记叙文
D. Feature Stories 新闻特写
Scan the passage and answer the questions.
1. What is the type of the text ?
2. What is the structure of this passage?
2. What is the structure of the passage?
The _________________ for that.
Part 1: Para. _____
The ____________ of the topic.
The ___________of the topic.
Part 2: Para. _____
Part 3: Para. _____
1
2-4
5
introduction
reasons/examples
conclusion
Read Para.1 and find out the author’s opinion on the movie adaptations.
All too often, great words end up being turned into cinematic “turkeys”.
Read for the details
Movie < Book
Read para 2 carefully and complete the chart.
What good
movies need Movies/Examples Comments
good stories
strong characters
impressive images
The Odyssey
The Great Gatsby
Alice in Wonderland
not as equally great
never be praised as “great”
just “interesting”
Read Para. 3-4 carefully and complete the chart.
Reasons for bad movies Examples Comments
Great books can ________________________________________________
Movies also disappoint us when
________________________________________________
with fans of books
____________________________________________
Actress who played Helen ______________________
didn’t live up to the book.
lose plot details and characters
when they move to the big
screen.
disappointed not to see some of their favourite characters in the movie versions.
things don’t look the way we imagined them in the books.
Read Para 5 and answer the questions.
① Conclusion:
Books and movies are two , and therefore have different .
②What does the writer advise us to do?
We should judge a movie in its own right.
different forms of media
rules
Harry Potter
The Great Gatsby
The Odyssey
Alice in Wonderland
The Iliad
Learning to learn
Functions of examples:
to explain ideas and concepts
to support arguments
to provide additional information
The Odyssey
The Great Gatsby
Alice in Wonderland
Harry Potter
Troy
All too often, great works end up being turned into cinematic “turkeys”.
Opinion
Great books can lose plot details and characters when they move to the big screen.
Reason 1
Movies should be judged in their own right.
Conclusion
Movies also disappoint us when things don’t look the way we imagined them
in the books.
Reason 2
Examples
retell&summary
1.What does the saying“There are a thousand Hamlets in a thousand people's eyes” mean? Do you know of any similar sayings in Chinese?
2. What other reasons do you think make movie adaptations not better than the original books?
Think and share
What does the saying“There are a thousand Hamlets in a thousand people's eyes” mean? Do you know of any similar sayings in Chinese?
It means different people have different ideas about the same thing. Everyone looks at things from their own view. So the same thing can be understood in many different ways.
仁者见仁,智者见智
What other reasons do you think make movie adaptations not better than the original books?
Because of the time limit and the aim of high profits, the filmmakers edit the storyline and remove most of the imagination.
Because the filmmakers don’t understand the original books well enough.
Because some actors can’t act out the characters’ feelings or emotions that are in the original books.
......
Homework
Read the text again and write a summary on the topic “Good book, bad movie?”
What books would you like to see made into movies? Why? Prepare to talk about it next class.
18
Lavf58.20.100
Packed by Bilibili XCoder v2.0.2
$